Healthy Living, Legal

The Details and Results of The Paul Mackoul, MD Lawsuit



Dr. Paul MacKoul, a highly esteemed medical professional, was embroiled in a legal conflict that caught the attention of the medical community and the public alike. The Dr. Paul Mackoul, MD lawsuit raised critical questions about medical ethics, professional conduct, and the complex dynamics between physicians and their patients.


MacKoul is a respected figure in the medical field, known for his significant contributions and unwavering commitment to his profession. However, in 2001, a complaint filed by a patient’s family began a series of events leading to a lawsuit against him.

The Allegation

In 2001, Dr. Paul Mackoul had his hospital privileges revoked due to a committee’s evaluation of his abilities and behavior as a doctor. The doctor inserted a catheter into the patient’s chest, despite lacking certification to perform cancer surgeries. The patient’s family filed a lawsuit, claiming that the doctor accidentally punctured a vein during the procedure. This mishap resulted in the accumulation of blood in her chest and a collapsed lung. The charges against him included unprofessional conduct in the practice of medicine, a violation of section 14-404(a)(3)(ii) of the Maryland Code.

Paul Mackoul, MD Lawsuit Proceedings

An Administrative Law Judge at the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) conducted a two-day hearing and issued a proposed decision in March 2013. The ALJ concluded that MacKoul was guilty of unprofessional conduct. Following an exceptions hearing before the Board in July 2013, the Board issued a final decision and order in June 2014.

The Reprimand

The Board’s final order imposed a reprimand on MacKoul, requiring him to complete a Board-approved intensive course on physician-patient interactions. This decision marked a significant point in the lawsuit, underscoring the severity of the allegations against MacKoul.

The Appeal

Unsatisfied with the Board’s decision, MacKoul appealed the verdict. He raised several questions about the scope of the charges and the judgment of the Board. He also questioned whether the factual findings supporting the issue before the Board had substantial evidence.

Client Reviews and Reputation

Notwithstanding the lawsuit, MacKoul’s reputation in the industry remained largely unscathed. Client reviews on various platforms depicted a dedicated and experienced professional. Many clients commended his competence, professionalism, and ability to simplify complex medical jargon.

Dr. Paul Mackoul’s Certifications and Specializations

  • Dr. Paul Mackoul is a certified specialist in gynecologic laparoscopy. This certification signifies his expertise in performing minimally invasive surgeries in the field of gynecology.
  • He has a certification in obstetrics and gynecology from the American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology.
  • Dr. Mackoul is also a member of the Society of Gynecologic Oncology.
  • Furthermore, he holds a certification in Robotic Surgery.
  • He is a specialist in Gynecologic Oncology, which involves the treatment of cancers that start in a woman’s reproductive organs.
  • Dr. Mackoul also specializes in advanced laparoscopic surgery.
  • He is also trained in performing hysterectomy procedures, which are surgeries to remove a woman’s uterus.
  • Dr. Mackoul has a fellowship in Gynecologic Oncology from the University of North Carolina, which provided him with intense specialized training in treating gynecological cancers.
  • He also specializes in complex pelvic surgery, which involves surgical procedures on the lower part of the woman’s abdomen and pelvis.


The Paul MacKoul MD lawsuit serves as a stark reminder of the complex nature of the medical profession. It underscores the delicate balance between upholding professional conduct and meeting patient expectations. While the lawsuit cast a shadow over MacKoul’s illustrious career, it is essential to remember the countless lives he has positively impacted through his dedicated service in medicine.

Final Thoughts

The case of MacKoul serves as an important case study for medical professionals and law practitioners alike. It reinforces the need for ongoing conversations about patient rights, professional conduct, and the legal implications of perceived misconduct. As the medical field continues to evolve, it becomes increasingly imperative to scrutinize and uphold the highest standards of professional conduct continually.

Paul Mackoul, MD Lawsuit FAQs

What was the result of the Paul Mackoul, MD Lawsuit?

A judge ordered Dr. Mackoul to take a course on physician-patient interactions.

Is Dr. Mackoul still practicing?

Yes, as of January 2024 he is still working as a gynecological surgical specialist.