The Dos and Don’ts of a Peer Review Template: How to Ensure Quality Feedback and Reviews

Welcome to the world of peer review!

As a researcher or an academician, you are no stranger to the process of submitting your work for review and feedback from your peers. Peer review is an essential part of any scientific research process as it helps in improving the quality and reliability of published work. However, not all peer reviews are created equal.

In this document, we will discuss the Dos and Don’ts of a peer review template to help you provide high-quality feedback and reviews.


The Dos of a Peer Review Template

When it comes to using a peer review template, there are certain dos and don’ts that reviewers should keep in mind. These guidelines can help ensure that the feedback provided is constructive and helpful for the author. Here are some of the dos of a peer review template, example, for FQHC:

Establish Clear Evaluation Criteria

When using a peer review template, it is crucial to establish clear evaluation criteria. This means identifying the specific aspects of the work that you will be evaluating and providing feedback on.

These criteria should be objective, measurable, and relevant to the overall goals of the work being reviewed. By establishing these criteria upfront, you can ensure that your feedback is focused and constructive. 

Use a Rating System

Another essential aspect of using a peer review template is incorporating a rating system. This allows you to assign scores or rankings to different aspects of the work being reviewed, making your feedback more specific and actionable. A rating system can also help the author understand which areas they excel in and which ones need improvement.

Provide Examples

These could be excerpts from the work being reviewed or references to other relevant sources. By providing examples, you can illustrate your points and make them more tangible for the author. This will also help them understand how they can improve their work.

The Don’ts of a Peer Review Template

While there are certain template guidelines that reviewers should follow, there are also some things that should be avoided. Here are the don’ts of a peer review template:

Don’t Be Vague

One of the biggest mistakes to avoid when using a peer review template is being vague in your feedback. It can be tempting to use broad or general statements, but this will not provide the author with useful information on how they can improve their work. Instead, be specific and provide examples to support your points.

Avoid Biases

As a reviewer, it is essential to avoid biases when using a peer review template. Your feedback should be based on the quality of the work, not personal opinions or preferences. It can be helpful to remind yourself to approach the review objectively and focus on providing constructive criticism.

Don’t Be Overly Critical

While it is crucial to provide honest feedback, it is equally important not to be overly critical. Remember that the goal of peer review is to help improve the work, not tear it down. 

Learn More About Peer Review Template

Using a peer review template can greatly improve the effectiveness and efficiency of the peer review process. 

Remember to establish clear evaluation criteria, use a rating system, provide examples, avoid biases, and not be overly critical in your feedback.

With these guidelines, you can help improve the quality of work in your field and contribute to the advancement of knowledge.

Visit our blog for more informative articles!